Highest Value Home Theatre PC

Despite the best efforts of the vast telecommunication companies, more and more television content is moving online. Of course, getting it to your TV can be a bit of a problem, but luckily there are a couple of inexpensive home theatre PCs that will help you get that content to your TV. There are a number of options, however, so which one should you pick? Here’s a few options, and their strengths and weaknesses.

Western Digital TV Live

Western Digital is best known for making hard drives. One of their devices that they’ve created is basically a hard drive that can also stream content to your television. Not only will it stream the majority of your media library off of your computer/network, but it also includes the ability to stream Netflix through an app built into the device. Other online content includes YouTube and Facebook access, again through built in apps off of the device. This device will cost about $100. From reviews online, it sounds like the biggest drawback is its interface. Western Digital is a hard drive company, not a user interface company, so while the device works well enough, it just doesn’t feel great. With a built in 1TB hard drive, this will cost about $200.

Boxee Box

Boxee is another little box that sits by your TV that allows online streaming content onto your TV. Boxee’s biggest flaw is that it is unable to stream content from your network/PC, so it is basically just a little Netflix machine. It’s biggest feature is that it will actually allow you to tune into basic analog cable coming into your house and even has an antenna in it to allow you to tune into HD digital over the air stations that may be available in your area. They are also trialing a “No Limit DVR” which is only available in select US cities, but it is basically the ability to record unlimited TV through the internet and then play it all back from the cloud for a monthly fee. Boxee’s start around $100.

Roku Box

Roku’s very similar to Boxee in that it is a tiny little box that is essentially for Netflix, Youtube, and other online apps. It cannot stream anything that you may already have. The difference would be that this little HTPC has apps for sports fans. If you subscribe to NFL Sunday Ticket or NHL Gamecenter then you can use this little guy to tune into those subscriptions and watch it on your TV. If you’re a sports fan and need a tiny PC to get your sports fix, this may be the best option. A Roku can be purchased for less than a hundred dollars.

Apple TV

An Apple TV will cost you at least $109. If you’re already part of the Apple ecosystem, then it may be the best choice for you. Besides having access to Netflix, Youtube, and other online streaming content, it will also sync very well with your other Apple devices. iOS devices can share all their content directly to your TV, even showing in real time what is happening on the smaller device. Of course, being Apple, it also has some features that cost more – like the ability to play certain music through the device can only be done through a monthly subscription. Other than that, you can also rent TV and Movies from Apple through the device. It can also stream content from your PC or Mac, but unfortunately it will only stream content that is inside iTunes. If you already use iTunes and if all your media is iTunes friendly, then this might be the easiest and most user friendly HTPC on the market.

Homemade HTPC

If you want something just a little more roboust, you may want to consider building your own HTPC. You can get a small computer case designed for use with your TV and put together a small part list that will give you a powerful PC, able to run any software you want to put on it. If you’re willing to invest around $300 and a few weekends worth of tinkering time, you can get the best possible HTPC for your home theatre. It will just cost some more. However, once you’re done, you’ll be able to stream any content on your network, have access to the entire internet (not just specific apps) and not have to worry about any type of provider specific limitation. If you want, you can even spend a little more money and get a video capture card so that you can record content from your TV provider.

Are you thinking about getting an HTPC? Which one makes the most sense for you?

Written by Alan Schram

Alan Schram writes about personal finance and his encounters with it in his everyday life. Alan is recently married and is looking to save money on expenses and reduce his debts.

3 Responses to Highest Value Home Theatre PC

  1. Andrew says:

    While this is a good overview of the options out there, it’s little a misleading, presumably because the author hasn’t used all the products extensively (understandably so). For example, I would point out that the Roku has many apps available for various content, including one called Plex that lets you enjoy video, music and photos from your PC. Knowing this made me choose Roku over the others; I’m loving it.

  2. Glenn Cooke says:

    I looked at a homebuilt system a few years ago but at the time the linux offerings weren’t very robust. Perhaps that’s changed.

    I’d like something that lets me replace cable – even if I have to use an antennae to combine local signals and internet, but I don’t think even today that’s really feasible.

  3. Jordan says:

    The boxee box does do network streaming. I’ve done it. What separates it from the WD TV and the Roku is that it is built off of XBMC. For those that don’t want to spend the dollars or time on a HTPC, Boxee is probably the best bet. 2 other options not mentioned: find an Apple TV2 at a reasonable price and hack it to run xbmc or run a version of XBMC off of a Raspberry Pi. Raspberry Pi Would probably be under $100 once you factor in the hardware, case, and remote.

Leave a reply

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Headline Name: Email: subscribed: 0 We respect your privacy Email Marketingby GetResponse